Skip to content
OfferLensCompare my offer

Compare · 6 min read · Updated November 2026

How to compare your mail offer against your other options

Use your pre-screened mail offer as a benchmark. A simple method to compare APR, fees, net cash and total cost across mail offers, online rate checks, banks and credit unions.

Our view: a real pre-screened offer is often the best deal you’ll see, because the lender has already looked at your credit and priced an offer for you. But “often” isn’t “always.” Treat your letter as the benchmark to beat, and spend twenty minutes checking.

Step 1: Write down your benchmark

  • APR (or the APR range if the letter shows one)
  • Origination fee, in dollars, and the net cash you’d receive
  • Term in months and the monthly payment
  • Total of payments (payment × months)

Step 2: Gather two or three comparisons, all with soft pulls

  • Other mail offers you’ve received recently, each with its own offer code
  • Your own bank or credit union. Federal credit unions cap most loan APRs at 18%
  • Rate checks on one or two lenders’ sites that say checking won’t affect your credit score

Step 3: Compare like with like

Line the offers up for the same amount and the same term. Compare APR first, then the total of payments, then the net cash. A no-fee loan at a slightly higher rate can still cost less than a lower rate with a big fee, and vice versa. APR settles it for equal terms.

What to compareWhy
APRIncludes interest and fees; the best single comparison number
Net cashWhat actually lands after an origination fee
Total of paymentsThe real cost over the full term
Monthly paymentMust fit your budget, but don’t compare on it alone
Discount conditionsAutopay or direct-pay discounts only count if you’ll keep them

Step 4: Read independent signals on the lender

Every lender profile on this site links to the CFPB complaint database, the Better Business Bureau and Trustpilot so you can read what other borrowers report. Look for patterns, not single angry reviews.

Step 5: Get an independent read on the letter itself

Before you respond, photograph your offer with the free LendMail Advisor. LendMail Advisors, our third-party evaluator, explains what the offer is and what the fine print says, and points you to the lender’s official response page.

General information, not financial advice. OfferLens is not a lender and earns no money from any lender or link.